• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels: A Taste of Italy in Mahopac

At Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels, we celebrate authentic Italian baking in a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Nestled in Mahopac, this bakery is renowned for its delectable pastries, soft muffins, and freshly baked bagels, all made with a passion that reflects our commitment to quality. Customers rave about our beautifully crafted treats, such as mouthwatering chocolate mousse and flaky pastries filled with tender apples. With a cozy vibe, friendly staff, and reasonable prices, Cafe Piccolo is the perfect spot for a coffee break or a leisurely lunch. Join us to indulge in the tastes of Italy right in your neighborhood!

Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels at a glance

  • Address 935 S Lake Blvd Ste 2 Mahopac, NY 10541
  • Phone (845) 628-2233
  • Restaurant type Pastry shop .

Photos & Gallery

Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels: Reviews & Ratings

Rhay D
5

Loved the gluten free cookies especially the lintzers, gluten free biscottis and the prices are very reasonable. Rest of the group enjoyed cappuccinos and tiramisu cake. So many choices!!! Very nice people who've been there a long time. Looks like a homey, community vibe kind of place.

Cary G
5

OMG..Finally a local bakery that doesn't suck! Seriously- these guys are old school..the only thing they don't do on site is the bread. All cookies, cakes, pies etc are made there and the taste and quality is excellent. You will know when you take a first bite that this is the real deal- not grocery store. They have a european coffee machine so they do euro-class coffee drinks. I had a latte and it was great. Awesome! We will most definately be back.

Amy Liao
5

Really fresh pastries right by the North County Trailway. A fantastic option for a quick stop while biking . I highly recommend the raspberry rugelach and almond biscotti

JK Mitchell
5

Great espresso. Great, friendly service. I recommend the bacon and egg sandwich with salt and pepper.

John Malandrino
5

Literally the best bakery in our area and beyond. Everything fresh. The smell will remind you of the old days.

Rocco Gioia
5

Great place, the staff & Lou the owner treat you like family. Espresso is made homemade, not like that Starbucks crap! Pastries are always made fresh. I highly recommend going.

Larry Nissman
5

Stopped in here the other day for some espresso and dessert. Possibly the best cup of espresso I've had and the desserts were fresh and delicious. All of the baked goods on display also looked amazing and I will definitely return for coffee and pastry in the future.

Joan Smyth Dengler
5

Excellent bagels - exceptional for this far north. The sweets are out of this world - try the cream puffs and eclairs. Beautiful parfaits. Delicious fruit danish. I haven't tried everything, but I'm working on it. :-) Recommend highly.

Location

  • Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels
    Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels
    935 S Lake Blvd Ste 2 Mahopac, NY 10541 Hotline: (845) 628-2233

Welcome to Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels, a delightful hidden gem nestled in the heart of Mahopac, NY. Situated at 935 S Lake Blvd Ste 2, this charming bakery has become a beloved destination for both locals and visitors seeking authentic Italian baked goods. With an impressive array of pastries, bagels, and sandwiches, Cafe Piccolo has truly carved out its niche in the culinary landscape of the area.

What sets Cafe Piccolo apart is its commitment to quality and authenticity. Customers rave about the fresh, mouthwatering pastries that reflect traditional Italian baking techniques. A standout item is their flaky, apple-filled horseshoe-shaped pastry, which perfectly encapsulates the bakery's ethos: simple ingredients crafted with care. The flavors are balanced, and the textures are heavenly—each bite transports you to a quaint Italian bakery.

  • Mouthwatering Pastries: From soft muffins to rich chocolate mousse—perfect for special occasions, every pastry exudes warmth and flavor. Many patrons, including Kaitlyn L., have celebrated milestones with Cafe Piccolo's beautifully crafted desserts.
  • Stellar Customer Experience: The bakery prides itself on its welcoming atmosphere. As Robin H. notes, the staff's friendly and helpful demeanor creates a comfortable space to enjoy a cup of coffee and a freshly made sandwich or pastry.
  • Vegetarian Options: Cafe Piccolo offers a variety of vegetarian-friendly meals, making it an ideal spot for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic bagel with cream cheese or a nourishing Açaí bowl, options abound.
  • Convenience and Accessibility: With delivery services, private lot parking, and bike parking, getting your baked goods from Cafe Piccolo is a breeze. Plus, the establishment accommodates gender-neutral restrooms, ensuring a comfortable visit for all.

In addition to the noteworthy pastries, the coffee is consistently praised for its quality, making it an ideal pairing with any baked treat. With reasonable prices and a warm, casual atmosphere, it’s no wonder that loyal customers like d K. are willing to travel for these delicious offerings.

Cafe Piccolo Pastry & Bagels is not just a bakery; it's a place where community and culinary artistry intersect. With its recent renovations, the space is fresh and inviting, reflecting the care and dedication of its new owner who has breathed new life into this cherished establishment. Whether you’re here for a quick breakfast or a leisurely lunch with friends, you're guaranteed an experience that satisfies the palate and warms the heart.

So why not stop by? Your taste buds will thank you!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • In-store pick-up for online orders
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards